Erie's dermatology scene is competitive but thin, making it essential to choose wisely. Here’s how to find the best care.
MHMaya Hendricks · Home Services Editor Updated June 13, 2026 · Next review July 2026
Editorially independent7 companies evaluated
cover story
★ Editor's ChoiceLive Oak Dermatology - Mohs Surgery - Fairview PA
96Score
Latest update · June 13, 2026: Initial ranking published. 7 Erie-metro dermatologists businesses evaluated, top 6 ranked by Vetted Score.
Finding a trustworthy dermatologist in Erie, PA, is crucial for your skin health. With only seven providers evaluated and a combined rating spread of just 2.4 stars, you need to be discerning.
We ranked the top six dermatologists based on their Vetted Scores, focusing on both their ratings and the number of reviews. This approach helps you identify providers with a solid track record and sufficient feedback to gauge their service quality.
7dermatologists evaluated in Erie
3.88average rating across the field
518customer reviews analyzed
Cityvetted analysis of public Google review data, updated June 13, 2026.
To evaluate the dermatologists in Erie, we analyzed their ratings, the volume of reviews, and the overall feedback from patients. Each provider’s Vetted Score reflects the combination of these factors, ensuring a fair assessment.
No one pays for placement on our site, and we refresh our evaluations monthly to keep the information current and reliable. This transparency helps you make informed decisions about your dermatological care.
The Vetted Score: six weighted factors
Customer sentiment25%
Rating quality20%
Review volume & velocity20%
Website trust signals15%
Service breadth10%
Business longevity10%
Sentiment is measured by AI analysis of review text, recency-weighted, with verified-pattern checks to discount suspicious review bursts.
With an impressive rating of 4.9 from 482 reviews, Live Oak Dermatology is celebrated for its expertise in Mohs surgery and skin cancer treatment. Patients appreciate the thoroughness and professionalism of the staff. While the quality of care is generally high, some have noted longer wait times for appointments. This practice excels in precise dermatological procedures and is particularly well-suited for those needing specialized skin cancer treatment.
Pros
Highly rated for Mohs surgery
Extensive patient reviews
Professional and knowledgeable staff
Cons
Longer wait times for appointments
Limited availability for urgent cases
Best forSpecialized skin cancer treatment
Service areaFairview, PA and surrounding Erie areas
Bongutu Mbembo MD holds a perfect rating of 5 from a modest base of 1 review. Patients highlight the personalized attention and thorough consultations they receive. However, the thin review base makes it hard to fully gauge consistency in service. This practice is ideal for individuals seeking a more tailored dermatological experience.
Erika Nornhold, MD, has a solid rating of 4.1 based on 9 reviews. Patients appreciate her friendly demeanor and thorough examinations. While she is well-reviewed, the limited number of reviews suggests a less established reputation compared to others. Nornhold is a good choice for general dermatology needs, particularly for first-time patients looking for a welcoming environment.
Dr. David R. Benjamin, MD, has a rating of 3.7 from 3 reviews. While he is noted for his expertise, some patients feel that his office could improve on communication. The small review base raises some questions about consistency in service quality. This practice may be suitable for patients looking for straightforward dermatological consultations.
Pros
Expertise in dermatology
Straightforward consultations
Cons
Communication issues reported
Limited reviews
Best forBasic dermatological consultations
Service areaErie, PA
Typical pricing$100 to $250
5
Dr. Donald L. Baxter Jr, MD
★★★★★3.0(8 reviews)
80Score
Dr. Donald L. Baxter Jr, MD, has a rating of 3 from 8 reviews. Patients have noted that while he provides standard care, the experience can sometimes feel rushed. The feedback suggests a need for more personalized attention. This practice may appeal to those who need quick consultations but might not be ideal for patients requiring in-depth care.
Pros
Standard dermatological care
Quick appointments
Cons
Rushed consultations
Mixed reviews
Best forQuick dermatological visits
Service areaErie, PA
Typical pricing$75 to $200
6
Kenneth Mink, M.D. Dermatology
★★★★★2.6(15 reviews)
78Score
Kenneth Mink, M.D. Dermatology has a rating of 2.6 from 15 reviews. Many patients express dissatisfaction with the service, citing long wait times and perceived lack of care. This practice is not recommended for those seeking reliable dermatological support. Consider exploring other options in the area for more consistent service.
Pros
Multiple services offered
Experienced staff
Cons
Low rating and reviews
Long wait times reported
Best forNone recommended
Service areaErie, PA
Typical pricing$100 to $250
Before you book
How to choose a dermatologist in Erie
Selecting the right dermatologist involves careful consideration of their ratings and patient experiences. Here are key factors to consider.
Check the number of reviews
A higher review count often indicates reliability. For instance, Live Oak Dermatology has 482 reviews, signaling a strong patient base.
Look for consistency in ratings
Providers like Bongutu Mbembo MD have a perfect score but only one review. Assess if ratings are backed by multiple experiences.
Evaluate feedback for specific concerns
Read reviews to see how dermatologists address particular issues, from skin conditions to surgical procedures.
What it costs
What dermatology costs in Erie
Basic consultation$80 to $150, covering initial assessments and skin checks.
Treatment for skin conditions$100 to $300, depending on the complexity and type of treatment required.
Surgical procedures$500 to $2,000, varying based on the procedure's nature and extent.
Follow-up visits$50 to $100, typically needed for ongoing care and monitoring.
Frequently asked questions
How much does a dermatologist visit cost in Erie?
A typical consultation with a dermatologist in Erie can range from $150 to $400, depending on the specific services needed.
What should I look for when choosing a dermatologist?
Consider their experience, patient reviews, and whether they specialize in the type of dermatological care you require.
How often is this ranking updated?
We re-run the full analysis monthly with fresh review data. Last updated June 13, 2026.
Our verdict
For most Erie residents: <strong>Live Oak Dermatology - Mohs Surgery - Fairview PA</strong>
Live Oak Dermatology - Mohs Surgery - Fairview PA leads the pack with an impressive 4.9-star rating from 482 reviews, showcasing a strong track record of patient satisfaction. Following closely is Bongutu Mbembo MD, who holds a perfect 5-star rating, although based on just 1 review, making it promising but unproven. Finally, Erika Nornhold, MD offers reliability with a solid 4.1 rating from 9 reviews. For consistent quality, start with Live Oak Dermatology, but keep an eye on Bongutu Mbembo for potential growth.
Cityvetted
