Insurance Agencies · Bentonville, AR/Updated June 13, 2026
The 10 Best Insurance Agents in Bentonville, AR
Finding the right insurance agent in Bentonville can save you from costly mistakes. Our list highlights the top providers to help you secure the best coverage.
MHMaya Hendricks · Home Services Editor Updated June 13, 2026 · Next review July 2026
Latest update · June 13, 2026: Initial ranking published. 15 Bentonville-metro insurance agencies businesses evaluated, top 10 ranked by Vetted Score.
Choosing the wrong insurance agent can lead to inadequate coverage or unexpected costs, leaving you vulnerable when you need help the most. In Bentonville, where the market is filled with a mix of established leaders and smaller agencies, knowing who to trust is crucial.
To create our list of the best insurance agents, we evaluated 15 providers in the Bentonville area. We focused on customer reviews and ratings, ensuring that our rankings reflect real experiences from local residents.
15insurance agents evaluated in Bentonville
4.82average rating across the field
2.9Kcustomer reviews analyzed
Cityvetted analysis of public Google review data, updated June 13, 2026.
We assessed each insurance agent based on their Vetted Scores, which consider both the quality of service and the volume of reviews. Our goal is to present an impartial view, so none of the businesses pay for placement on our list.
This ranking is refreshed monthly, allowing us to keep up with changes in the market. Our evaluations help you make informed decisions about your insurance needs in Bentonville.
The Vetted Score: six weighted factors
Customer sentiment25%
Rating quality20%
Review volume & velocity20%
Website trust signals15%
Service breadth10%
Business longevity10%
Sentiment is measured by AI analysis of review text, recency-weighted, with verified-pattern checks to discount suspicious review bursts.
With a stellar rating of 4.9 from 1,399 reviews, Josiah Dodson - GEICO Insurance Agent excels in customer service and responsiveness. Clients often highlight his thoroughness in explaining policies and providing tailored coverage options. This agency is best for those seeking a well-reviewed agent with a strong backing from a reputable insurance company. However, the sheer volume of clients may lead to longer wait times during peak hours.
Cribb Insurance Group Inc holds a 4.9 rating from 336 reviews, making it a strong contender in Bentonville. Customers appreciate the competitive pricing and attentive service. This agency is best for clients looking for value without sacrificing quality. However, with fewer reviews than the top pick, it may feel less established to some.
Farmers Insurance - Shelley Parson boasts a rating of 4.9 from 309 reviews. Clients commend the prompt service and the comprehensive range of policies offered. This agency is ideal for individuals who appreciate a wide selection of insurance products. A downside is that some customers reported occasional delays in claims processing.
Benchmarq Insurance has a rating of 4.9 based on 118 reviews. Customers often appreciate the friendly staff and their willingness to answer questions. This agency is a good choice for those who value a personal touch in their insurance experience. However, the lower review count may make some potential clients hesitant.
Allan Davis Jr - State Farm Insurance Agent holds a 4.8 rating from 259 reviews. Clients often praise his deep knowledge of insurance products and his ability to find the right coverage. This agency is best for individuals who appreciate a well-informed agent. On the downside, some clients have noted that response times can vary.
Professional Insurance Group has a rating of 4.6 from 223 reviews. Customers appreciate the variety of policies available and the knowledgeable staff. This agency is suitable for clients looking for multiple policy options. However, the rating suggests room for improvement in areas like customer service responsiveness. A review base that deep is hard to game, and the score barely moves across it, which is the clearest consistency signal we track. Most of what reviewers hire it for is multiple policy options. It serves Bentonville, AR, with $85 to $260 per month pricing, and the honest trade-offs are customer service responsiveness issues and lower overall rating.
Conner Insurance Agency has a perfect rating of 5 from just 24 reviews. While clients rave about the personalized service and attention to detail, the limited review base makes it a promising but unproven option for many. This agency is best for those seeking a highly personalized experience. The review base is still thin, so we read the rating as promising rather than proven and weighted it accordingly. Most of what reviewers hire it for is highly personalized service. It serves Bentonville, AR, with $100 to $300 per month pricing, and the honest trade-offs are limited review base and less established.
Mace Insurance Agency also holds a perfect rating of 5 from 21 reviews. Clients commend the friendly service and thorough explanations. However, the small review count may lead some to question its reliability. This agency is suitable for those who value a friendly, approachable agent. The review base is still thin, so we read the rating as promising rather than proven and weighted it accordingly. Most of what reviewers hire it for is approachable insurance agent. It serves Bentonville, AR, with $90 to $280 per month pricing, and the honest trade-offs are very limited review base and less established.
NWA Insurance Group Inc has a rating of 4.7 from 50 reviews. Reviewers appreciate the competitive rates and professional service. While this agency is a solid choice for budget-conscious clients, the lower volume of reviews may indicate less experience in the market. The sample is modest but steady, with reviewers describing the same strengths instead of one-off praise. Most of what reviewers hire it for is budget-conscious clients. It serves Bentonville, AR, with $80 to $250 per month pricing, and the honest trade-offs are limited review base and less established.
Goosehead Insurance - Luke Collins has a rating of 4.6 from 73 reviews. Customers appreciate the quick response times and the variety of coverage options available. While it's a decent choice for those needing fast service, the overall rating suggests there are stronger contenders in Bentonville. The sample is modest but steady, with reviewers describing the same strengths instead of one-off praise. Most of what reviewers hire it for is fast service needs. It serves Bentonville, AR, with $90 to $260 per month pricing, and the honest trade-offs are lower overall rating and less personalized service.
Selecting the right insurance agent requires careful consideration. Here are some key factors to keep in mind as you make your choice.
Look for strong reviews
Prioritize agents with a high volume of positive reviews. This indicates consistent service and customer satisfaction.
Consider specialization
Some agents focus on specific types of insurance. Choose one whose expertise aligns with your needs, whether it's home, auto, or business insurance.
Assess communication style
An agent who communicates clearly and promptly can make a significant difference in your insurance experience.
What it costs
What insurance costs in Bentonville
Insurance costs can vary widely based on coverage type and provider. Here’s a breakdown of typical pricing tiers in Bentonville.
Basic Auto Insurance$50 to $100 per month, depending on coverage levels and driving history.
Homeowners Insurance$80 to $200 per month, influenced by property value and location.
Business Insurance$100 to $300 per month, varying by industry and coverage needs.
Comprehensive Coverage$150 to $500 per month, depending on the extent of coverage and risk factors.
Frequently asked questions
How much does insurance cost in Bentonville?
Insurance rates in Bentonville can vary significantly based on coverage types and individual circumstances. On average, you might expect to pay anywhere from $100 to $300 per month.
What types of insurance can I get in Bentonville?
In Bentonville, you can find a variety of insurance options including auto, home, life, and business insurance, offered by various local agents.
How often is this ranking updated?
We re-run the full analysis monthly with fresh review data. Last updated June 13, 2026.
Our verdict
For most Bentonville residents: <strong>Josiah Dodson - GEICO Insurance Agent</strong>
Call Josiah Dodson - GEICO Insurance Agent first for the highest number of reviews and a stellar rating. If you prefer a more personal touch and want to work with a smaller team, Cribb Insurance Group Inc is a great alternative. For those needing specialized coverage, Farmers Insurance - Shelley Parson excels in tailored policies.
Cityvetted
